• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Intelligence 101

Teaching You About Intelligence Analysis

Online Intelligence Training – Foundation Training For Intelligence Analysts 

  • Get Started Here
  • HOMETake me back
  • ABOUTWhat We’re About
  • All-Source IntelligenceSee All Our Blog Posts Here
    • Analytical Tradecraft
    • All Source Intelligence
    • Criminal Intelligence
    • Human Intelligence (HUMINT)
    • Imagery Intelligence (IMINT)
    • Intelligence Agencies
    • Measurement and Signature Intelligence (MASINT)
    • Military Intelligence
    • Open Source Intelligence
    • Psychological Operations (PSYOPS)
    • SIGINT
    • Spying and Espionage
    • Surveillance
  • RESOURCESTools of the Trade
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Ebook
    • Open Source Intelligence Masterclass
    • Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf
  • CONTACTGet in contact

Sherman Kent

What’s Your Level Of Certainty? On Words of Estimative Probability

By Ben Stark on July 13, 2018 2

Let me ask you a question –

 

Question: “How sure are you?”

Answer:

a) “I’m pretty sure”

b) “There’s a high potential”

c) “I’m not uncertain”

d) None of the above.

In this weeks article, we discuss this article on ‘words of estimative probability’.

Now before your eyes glaze over and you scroll to the funny gifs, here’s why this article matters:

Intelligence professionals deal in uncertainty, so we need a common language and shared understanding.

Eh?

Ok, Let me take you back to the 1960’s when Sherman Kent (<- kind of a big deal) wrote a classified article for the CIA titled “Words of Estimative Probability.”

Problem: In his article, Kent discusses the need for common words to provide estimative meaning in intelligence assessments.

Why?

Intelligence requires us to make predictions, to give estimates and provide assessments.

To do this, we need to be able to qualify what we mean. We need a common language and a shared understanding.

Intelligence is NOT an exact science

Remember: Assessments are predicated on your understanding of the situation, and the quality / volume of information available.

A ‘probability’ is based on a ‘best guess’ –  more quality information allows for a greater degree of certainty when making an assessment.

So what are the odds?

I was taught to use the following words to provide an intelligence assessment – Each of these words used a ‘percentages of probability’

  • Unlikely <15%,
  • Possible >15%,
  • Likely >50%,
  • Probable >75%, and
  • Certain >95%.

Kent Says: 

Considerations

  • Don’t Modify. Importantly, when using the terms above, we don’t add ‘modifiers’, such as; ‘very possible’ or ‘highly likely’, as these can change the meaning and confuse.
  • Not all information is created equal. Just because there might be more reporting doesn’t automatically increase the probability. Quality beats quantity.

Adoption

Everyone needs to speak the same language – what’s the point of me telling you something is ‘certain’ if you interpret it as ‘certainly possible’.

In Summary

Intelligence professionals deal in uncertainty, so we need a common language and shared understanding. Intelligence still needs shared terms to building collective understandings.

I’ve had a few people offer different various terms or percentages – let me know what you think?  Do you use these words? are the percentages consistent with your assessments? Does this method accurately quantify a qualitative assessment?

 

Check out:

  • The Moscow Rules: 10 Rules Every Spy Should Live By
  • Intelligence Analyst Bookshelf – Essential Reading
  • Information vs Intelligence

Primary Sidebar

Best of Intelligence101

  • PSYOPS: The ULTIMATE Guide to Psychological Operations (PSYOPS)
  • Known Unknowns: Unpacking Information Requirements and the Direction phase of the Intelligence Cycle
  • Intelligence Failures: 3 Reasons How (and Why) Intelligence F#$K-ups Occur
  • “I Need You To Tell Me What’s Going On Here”: Analyse the Situation and Provide a Quick Assessment
  • 7 Opportunities for Criminal Intelligence Professionals During the COIVD-19 Crisis

Get Our Newsletter

INTREP: Do You Want To Be A Better Intelligence Analyst? Want Weekly Intelligence Tips and Techniques? Join Our Mailing List Below...

100% privacy. No games, no B.S., no spam. When you sign up, we'll keep you posted with one an email per week.

Categories

  • About Intelligence 101 (1)
  • All Source Intelligence (3)
  • Become A Better Intelligence Analyst (19)
  • Bias (2)
  • Cipher & Crypto (1)
  • Counter-Intelligence (1)
  • Criminal Intelligence (1)
  • Cyber Intelligence (Hacking) (1)
  • Human Intelligence (HUMINT) (2)
  • Imagery Intelligence (IMINT) (1)
  • Intelligence 101 (11)
  • Intelligence Agencies (3)
  • Intelligence Case Studies (2)
  • Intelligence Cycle (1)
  • Intelligence Operations (2)
  • Intelligence Resources (3)
  • Intelligence Training (5)
  • Interview Series (2)
  • Measurement and Signature Intelligence (MASINT) (1)
  • Military Intelligence (1)
  • Open Source Intelligence (2)
  • Political Intelligence (1)
  • Psychological Operations (PSYOPS) (2)
  • Resources (1)
    • Product and Service Reviews (1)
  • Security Intelligence (1)
  • SIGINT (1)
  • Spying and Espionage (1)
  • Surveillance (1)
  • Uncategorized (8)

Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf_ Essential Reading For Intelligence Professionals
99 of the BEST Intelligence Resources
How do you coup?
Crowdsourced Intelligence: Advantages, Disadvantages & How You Can Get Involved!
Knowledge is Powe(r) – A Crash Course in Ciphers, Codes, and Cryptography (Feat. Simon Bacon & William Friedman)
Intelligence Training Scenario
Intelligence101 Foundation Training Online Intelligence Course
24 Lessons Learnt From a Decade of Intelligence_ How to create Intelligence that matters
  • About
  • Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions
  • Get Started Here
  • Intelligence Frequently Asked Questions
  • Blog Posts
  • Intelligence101 – Online Intelligence Analysis Course
  • Free Intelligence Training: Review of Level 1 Intelligence Analysis Course by Robert Folker

Copyright © 2021 · Smart Passive Income Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in