• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Intelligence 101

Teaching You About Intelligence Analysis

Become a Better Intelligence Analyst – Get Started Here!

  • Get Started Here
  • HOMETake me back
  • ABOUTWhat We’re About
  • All-Source IntelligenceSee All Our Blog Posts Here
    • Analytical Tradecraft
    • All Source Intelligence
    • Criminal Intelligence
    • Human Intelligence (HUMINT)
    • Imagery Intelligence (IMINT)
    • Intelligence Agencies
    • Measurement and Signature Intelligence (MASINT)
    • Military Intelligence
    • Open Source Intelligence
    • Psychological Operations (PSYOPS)
    • SIGINT
    • Spying and Espionage
    • Surveillance
  • RESOURCESTools of the Trade
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Ebook
    • Open Source Intelligence Masterclass
    • Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf
  • CONTACTGet in contact

Ben Stark

The Moscow Rules: Unpacking the 10 Rules Every Spy Should Live By

By Ben Stark on June 15, 2018 0

The Moscow Rules: Unpacking the 10 Rules Every Spy Should Live By

‘The Moscow Rules’ are a set of directives said to have been developed during the Cold War to be used by spies and others working in Moscow. The rules are associated with Moscow because the city developed a reputation as being a particularly harsh locale for clandestine operatives who were exposed.

In this article we unpack the 10 Moscow Rules and discuss if they’re still relevant today… (spoiler: they are) so read on. 

Moscow Rule 1: Assume nothing.

The first of the Mosco rules, tells intelligence officers to put their preconceived notions, ideas and bias to the side. If I was writing the list of traits for intelligence professionals, being sceptical would be somewhere up the top.

You’ve probably all heard the saying; ‘assume nothing & question everything’, and in the often murky world of intelligence, these are words to live by.

“Nothing is what it seems”  – The Recruit (Movie)

Since intelligence professionals often deal in half-truths, concealed agendas and incomplete information; here are a couple of easy techniques you can use to place an analytical lens over information or scenarios as they unfold.

Remember;

  • Every conversation has a subtext – so ask yourself, what are they really trying to say? Or, perhaps, why are they telling me this right now?
  • Second, always consider someone’s agenda. Ask yourself, ‘what is their motivation…?’ because everyone has one.

Moscow Rule 2: Never go against your gut.

During a recent hold’em poker tournament –I raised my opponents’ bet because I was so sure I had him beat.

I was holding the middle pair (a pair of 10s)… but after he pushed ‘all in’ over the top, I talked myself down – rationalising, and recalling the action.

Eventually, I conceded I must be beaten, so I folded my hand – face down. As I did, my opponent stood in a triumphant display of macho aggressiveness and showed me a bluff – he had nothing.

I was seething. I knew he had nothing. I should have trusted my gut!

We’ve all been in that position before right? Whether you’re talking to someone you don’t believe – or when things just don’t seem right…

If you feel like a distraction from work, check out Magnus Walkers TedX talk about the importance of following your gut here (19 minutes) –

Here’s how this principle applies to the world of Intelligence:

  • There’s no artificial intelligence that can deduce intelligence and logic like the human brain. We’re capable of combining feelings, experiences, thought and logic to shape opinions and form unique assessments. Your ‘gut’ feeling, comes from previous experience, lessons learnt and your worldview – so trust it.
  • Second, don’t be afraid to disagree, if your opinion differs from the norm, but your gut tells you you’re right – don’t be afraid to listen to that little voice inside. Remeber what Mark Twain wrote; ‘when you find yourself on the side of the majority, its time to pause and reflect.’

Moscow Rule 3: Everyone is potentially under opposition control.

Ultimately this could be written a second way: trust no-one.

Whilst I understand, a culture of hyper-vigilance might be bad for making new friends, in the world of intelligence professionals, assume the worst and hope for the best.

The reality is, whilst not everyone will be under opposition control, using this as a default will mean you approach relationships with some scepticism and ensure you protect yourself before letting your guard down.

I caution against oversharing during first interactions and be wary of people who lead the conversation to topics you like, enjoy or feel passionate about.

Moscow Rule 4: Don’t look back; you are never completely alone.

Picture this. You’re an intelligence officer operating in a foreign country.

You’ve left the security of your cover job to meet with an asset at a pre-arranged location.

Your goal here is to avoid being suspicious.

Counter surveillance 101 – don’t look back!

Think of how it would look to you if the person walking down the street in front of you kept looking back over their shoulder. Imaging watching someone glancing from left to right, watching out for cameras or people following them in shop windows. Act natural and don’t draw attention to yourself, which brings us to the next rule…

Moscow Rule 5: Go with the flow, blend in.

In line with the previous rule, this rule is about ‘blending-in’. In essence, this rule can be summed up with the following actions – Bore the shit out of them and become the grey man.

Here are a few tips,

  • Determine a ‘baseline’ – identify what is ‘normal’ in order to fit into that environment. Example, you’re not going to wear a suit to the beach (or a bikini in the boardroom).
  • Act as if… If you want to look like a tourist, get out your map, have your travel guide in your hand and start taking photos. If you want to look like a local, use a branded shopping bag, pick up a newspaper or put on some headphones.
  • Avoid eye contact! It’s a simple thing – but making eye contact will trigger a stimulus in someone and cause them to register your presence. If you want to remain the grey man, avoid making eye contact.

Moscow Rule 6: Vary your pattern and stay within your cover.

When I was deployed overseas, each time we would step out on patrol we varied our patrol times, places and the routes we took to avoid becoming predictable.

This rule suggests you vary your patterns which might mean getting coffee from a different café, leaving the house earlier (or later), or driving a different route to work.

Vary your route to avoid detection
Vary your route to avoid detection

How to stay within your cover;

Be boring. If you’ve haven’t seen the TV series ‘the Americans’, the characters, who are a ‘Russian sleeper agents’ try to maintain their cover by having a fairly inconspicuous travel agency. Pretty boring.

Be authentic. If you’re using a cover, make sure you know the details – there’s no point in pretending to be a plutonium scientist if you don’t know the meaning of neutron flux.

Remember you’ve got an accent – don’t pretend to be a nationality you’re not. That’s just dumb.

Here are two (external) articles about remaining undetected and staying undercover:

  • A C.I.A. Grunt’s Tale of the Fog of Secret War
  • How Do Spies Keep Their Double Lives Secret?

Moscow Rule 7: Lull them into a sense of complacency

People become complacent when they’re secure, or feel in control. Allowing people to become complacent, means they might pay less attention to details – or less scrutiny.

How can you lull someone into a sense of complacency?

  • You can reassure someone of what they already know.
  • Allow them to see the outcome or the endpoint before it occurs.
  • Make a situation appear like many others before it.
  • Allow someone to feel in control, like they’re making the decisions.

Moscow Rule 8: Don’t harass the opposition

Why would you want to make your life more difficult – or invite unnecessarily scrutiny to your actions? Although you might enjoy the excitement, it’s short lived, and probably won’t end well.

I once heard of a bank robber called the ‘post-card bandit’ who would send letters to the police, gloating of his success and in essence taunting them to catch him. Eventually, after the media caught wind of the letters – they established a task force and tracked him down.

That’s about as smart as this guy who taunted Chinese Police to ‘come and catch him’ – they did. 

Lesson: “Don’t poke the bear!

Moscow Rule 9: Pick the time and place for action.

This is key – act on your time, at a place of your choosing.

Arranging any meeting, or activity should be on your terms.

This avoids being caught off guard, unprepared, or without a full and detailed understating of the operating environment.

I practice this daily – by choosing not to answer unknown numbers – if I don’t know who is calling, and I choose not to be caught off guard.

Remember to remain in control.

Moscow Rule 10: Keep your options open

There are two meanings to this rule;

First, opportunity abounds – who knows when the right person or piece of information will present itself. Remaining open to different options at any time means being ready to react or capitalise on opportunities.

Second, never remaining fixed to one idea, or to one plan. For example, Army officers, for example, are tested on ever-changing scenarios to test their flexibility and ability to processes changing the environment.

Keeping your options open means not being fixed on a specific outcome. If something changes, asses the situation, and react.

Always have a contingency. Think: if this, then what…

So they’re The Moscow Rules, as displayed in the International Spy Museum in Washington, D.C. Let me know your thoughts, experiences and whether you think it’s about time the Moscow Rules were updated or if they’ve stood the test of time…

 

Also: 

  • My foolproof process to writing a killer intelligence brief and tips to deliver intelligence assessments better.
  • Six [Sometimes Awekward] Truths About Intelligence Analysis
  • How to become a better intelligence analyst?

How To Identify Analytical Thought Wells – And Why They Matter For Intelligence Professionals!

By Ben Stark on June 8, 2018 0

How To Identify Analytical Thought Wells – And Why They Matter For Intelligence Professionals!

It’s easy to believe we always approach issues logically, but in fact, our reasoning is often fallible. Sometimes we get ‘stuck’ in different thought patterns, also known as ‘thought wells’.

I recently picked up an easy-to-read book called “Think smart, act smart – 101 ways to be effective and decisive” when I got the chapter about ‘thought wells’ realised how relevant this is for intelligence professionals.

Here are seven common thought wells intelligence professionals might find themselves in: 

1) Denial or Avoidance. Refusing to deal with unpleasant facts either by denying their existence or avoiding action needed to deal with it.

2) Yes, But… Coming up with a variety of reason, however spurious, of why a new idea won’t work instead of exploring its possibilities.

3) Groupthink. Automatically accepting the opinions of others without first checking whether or not their assumptions are correct.

4) Selective Vision. Trying to make the facts of a situation conform to your previously reached conclusions.

5) One Track Mind. Refusal to recognise any need for new thinking. People tend to find it difficult to reverse a decision once its made (even if it was a mistake).

6) Over Complicating Matters. Ignoring the simplest explanation or solution in favour of an overly complex or less likely one – remember the principle of Occam’s Razor!

7) Not My Idea. Dismissing an idea just because someone else thought of it.

Can you recognise any of these ‘thought wells’ in yourself? I certainly can. Let me know your best way you overcome any of the ‘thought wells’ above and we’ll feature your tips to help our audience avoid biases, and become better intelligence professionals.

 

You Might Also Like: 

  • My Favourite Movies About Spies, Spying, Intelligence and Espionage
  • Intelligence Tradecraft: Why ‘Done’ Is Better Than ‘Perfect’

Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf: Essential Reading For Intelligence Professionals

By Ben Stark on February 12, 2018 1

Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf: Essential Reading For Intelligence Professionals

Essential Reading For Intelligence Professionals: A list of texts, books and readings for Intelligence Professionals. Enjoy.

My Top 5:

1. Tiger Trap: Americas Secret War with China by David Wise. FBI Espionage, Counter Intelligence, and Chinese spying! What more could you ask for? I finished this book in about two days and 100% recommend it for anyone interested in the Intelligence Collection processes, Chinese Agent Infiltration, and Chinese influence in America.

2. Structured Analytic Techniques for Intelligence Analysis by Richard J Heuer. If you could only ever buy ONE book on the topic of Intelligence Analysis this would be it! Every decent analyst worth their salt knows the name Richard Heuer (probably best known for his Psychology of Intelligence Analysis – available to download in PDF here). However, for me, this book outlines over 50 analytic tools and technics. For me, this book is the HOLY BIBLE for Intelligence Analysts. Enough said!

3. Handbook of Scientific Methods of Inquiry for Intelligence Analysis by Henry W. Prunckun. I’m love Analytical Tools. In fact. I’m probably an Intelligence technique Junkie – I can’t get enough of them, SWOT, PEST, Pareto Analysis, Brainstorming, Devil’s Advocate, I print these techniques out and put them up in my office (lame I know). But still, I find they help to guide analysis and provide that new or difference ‘lense’ to see infromation differently. Well that’s what Professor Prunckun provides here. All you can eat analytical technics, nom, nom, nom…

4. The Art and Science of Intelligence Analysis by Julian Richards. Is Intelligence Art or Science?? What do you think? Well I’m inclined to believe the discipline is both ‘art’ and ‘science’. Overall, my belief is Intelligence borrows from both disciplines, but I only say that after reading and reviewing these type of Intelligence texts. Recommended for Intelligence and Practitioners alike, for a more in depth summary and review, check out this review by Angela Gendron here.

 

5. The Art of War by Sun Tzu. The preeminent text on military strategy and one of the most influential books ever written. Its wisdom and teachings are just as relevant today, over 2500 years since the Art of War was first written. If you haven’t read this text, reserve some time on a lazy Sunday afternoon, put the kettle on and settle in. This is essential reading.

  • “Appear weak when you are strong, and strong when you are weak.”
  • “The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting.”
  • “If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles.

Analytical Tools and Tradecraft:

 

Critical Thinking for Strategic Intelligence by Katherine Hibbs Pherson and Randolph H. Pherson.Critical Thinking for Strategic Intelligence Organized around twenty key questions that all analysts should ask as they prepare to conduct research, draft papers, and present their analysis. Also includes a set of case studies that the reader can use to reinforce understanding of the key points in the book.

Intelligence Analysis: A Target-Centric Approach by Robert P Clark. An excellent resource for students and potential intelligence analysts. Clark provides and educational and practical text on intelligence analysis and insight into Scenario Planning, Bayesian Analysis, and the proper use of intelligence. There’s a reason this book ranks so highly on Amazon for Intelligence!

Psychology of Intelligence AnalysisPsychology of Intelligence Analysis by Richards Heuer. I mentioned this text above, and in case you missed it – you can download a free PDF copy of this here. Originally written for Intelligence Analysts at the CIA Psychology of Intelligence Analysis is a must read for anyone studying or interested in the theory of Intelligence Analysis. Moreover, this book applies to policy analysts, lawyers, law-enforcement and anyone working in the field of global security analysis. Recommended Reading (and free).

Spies, Spying, Espionage & Counter Intelligence:

By Way of Deception: The Making and Unmaking of a Mossad Officer by Victor Ostrovsky. This book provides an intriguing insight into “the institute” through the authors’ recount of his recruitment, training and career postings in the secretive Israeli Mossad.

Circle of Treason: A CIA Account of Traitor Aldrich Ames and the Men He Betrayed by Sandra Grimes.  At the time of his arrest Aldrich Ames had compromised more CIA assets than any other mole in history. Spying for the Russians’ Ames was a CIA Counter-intelligence analyst who turned against the US government and was convicted of espionage in 1994. This book (and later a TV Series – The Assets) was written by Sandra Grimes a member of the CIA team who ultimately exposed Ames.

Spymaster: My Thirty-two Years in Intelligence and Espionage Against the West by Oleg Kalugin. A fascinating story of a KBG Officer who exposed soviet Intelligence tactics and details of his postings as an undercover agent in the United States.

 

The Great Game: The Myth and Reality of Espionage by Frederick P. Hitz. Sometimes the truth can be stranger than fiction. And often, a good spy novel might be borne from a real life incident. In this book our Author (Hitz) draws on both fact and fiction as he dives into the fascinating world of espionage. Here we get a comparison of fictional spies compared to ‘what actually goes on’ and Hintz sheds light on the real life motivations of some well-known and ‘infamous’ spies.

Why Spy?: Espionage In An Age of Uncertainty by Frederick P. Hitz. The Hitz keep on coming…! Anybody? No? Ok, moving on. This second book by Author Frederick Hitz delves into the murky world of recruiting spies. Want to know what motivates someone to risk their life in the often dangerous world of espionage? Well our author here does a fantastic job of revealing this in detail. Recommended if you’re interested in the CIA, HUMINT and Source Recruitment.

Terrorism, Counter-Terrorism, Jihad & the Middle East:

Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam by Gilles Kepel. A comprehensive text on Islamist History, the author provides a great analysis of the events of the Islamic world from the second half of the 20th century. Although you could call this text a little controversial (not everyone agrees with his analysis), recommended for anyone studying Islamic politics, international relations in the Middle East, Intelligence and Terrorism.

Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and Bin Laden, from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001 by Steve Coll. A 20 year look into the US relations with Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Afghanistan in the lead up to 11 September 2001. The author chooses to stop here, and instead focus on the complex issues that existed with all these parties in the lead up to this date. He provides a very detailed analysis on CIA activity in Afghanistan (hence the ‘ghost’ part of the title), and discusses American policy on Central Asia. Good for students of Terrorism, Islamic Politics, International Relations in the Middle East and Intelligence Analysts.

Classic Tests, Military History and Intelligence Theory:

On War by Carl von Clausewitz. Its’ a pity Clausewitz never actually got to finish this classic before his death. Published posthumously by his wife, Clausewitz’s writing goes down in history as one of the most important treatises on the relationship between politics and war. Spoiler: according to some strategists Clausewitz general message was “War must never be seen as having any purpose in itself, but should be seen as an instrument of politics.”

The Prince by Machiavelli. Is it better to be feared than loved? You tell me! Welcome to one of the most controversial books ever written – and actually made the Catholic Church’s list of prohibited books. You’ve probably heard quotes from the book at some point in your life – Every time I see this book on my bookshelf I want to re-read it. Despite being over 500 years old, the text deals with the practical realities of getting and holding power.

Intelligence In War by John Keegan. Sometimes Intelligence is the whipping boy of strategy, blamed if things go wrong (re: Intelligence Failures) by ignored when we get it right. In this book, author John Keegan finally acknowledges some split-second decisions made with the aid of timely and accurate intelligence – finally, some recognition. Recommended for military historians and anyone looking for some comprehensive intelligence wins.

Go Spy the Land: Military Intelligence in History by Keith Neilson and B.J.C. Mckercher. Have you ever pondered what role Intelligence played in Military History? This book (a collection of nine essays) span the role of intelligence in military conflict from Ancient Rome, the Spanish Armada and through the 16th, 17th and 18th centuries. I wouldn’t say this book is light reading – it should be of interest and recommended to military historians or anyone interested in the role of intelligence in military history.

The Art of Intelligence: Lessons from a Life in CIA’s Clandestine Service by Henry A. Crumpton. In spite of all the bureaucracy, Author Henry Crumpton paints a pretty rosy picture of the US CIA by focusing on the capability, and efforts on the people in the field. Shedding light on the CIAs involvement into Afghanistan (early 2001-2002) through the authors’ eyes this book provides an insight into intelligence and espionage from someone who’s actually been there and can tell the tale.

Critical Thinking to Make you a Better Intelligence Professional (By reading these Books):

The Tet Offensive: Intelligence Failure in War by James Wirtz. Not everyone knows the Tet Offensive was a huge intelligence failure. But they should. What happened? Well, in summary, basically no one believed the North Vietnamese would launch a coordinated attack on the Vietnamese New Year (known and Tet)…but they did. Oops. There’s a lesson about assumptions and testing bias this for all would be Intelligence Analysts, read, learn, & enjoy. Thanks Mr Wirtz.

Intelligence Analysis: How to Think in Complex Environments by Wayne Michael Hall and Gary Citrenbaum. Written by two seasoned Intelligence professionals, this book shows us “how to think” not “what to think” in an age of information overload. In fact, I recently posted an article on these topics (shameless self-promotion here), and feel this text gets to the heart of what Intelligence analysts need to focus on. More information is not always better – it’s what the information means that matters most! If I were running an intelligence course, especially at a tertiary level, this would be required reading.

Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking by M. Neil Browne and Stuart M. Keeley. Question: How do you bridge the gap between accepting information and critically analysing what it means? Answer: With this book! Keeley provides a common sense text for critical thinking and for improving communication. Two skills are paramount to any good intelligence analyst! I would put this book in the recommended reading section for students of intelligence or anyone learning how to become an effective interviewers (eg. Police, journalists and of course Intelligence Officers).

Analyzing Intelligence: Origins, Obstacles, and Innovations by Roger Z. George and James B. Bruce Editors. Einstein said “If you can’t explain it simply, then you don’t understand it well enough.” And our authors do a fantastic job of taking what can be a complex subject and deliver it in a way anyone can understand. Well done. Also, if for no other reason, read this book for its cool title page. Props!

Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman. With over 1,963five star reviews, the author clearly knows his content. This book provides an insight into how we think; fast – i.e. automatically, quick and intuitively, and slow; i.e. choice and concentration. For Intelligence analysts an understanding of how we receive, process and analyses information is paramount to be able to spot bias and develop robust assessments. Look, I’m not going to lie – it’s a big book, and there’s a lot there…but you’ll be better for it.

Recommended Fiction, and non-fiction

Brave New World by Aldous Huxley. Along with 1984, Brave New World is the masthead of dystopian fiction. I originally read this book in School, and loved it – now, I recommended this book (along with 1984, and Animal Farm) as essential reading!

 

Meditations by Marcus Aurelius. As of the time of writing I’ve only just started reading this book. I’m not sure why, but I feel a real pull to read this, perhaps just to reflect – but this text, is a series of personal writings written by Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius (161-180 CE) written for his own personal development.

  • “The happiness of your life depends upon the quality of your thoughts: therefore, guard, accordingly, and take care that you entertain no notions unsuitable to virtue and reasonable nature.”

So that’s it, So far. What can you guys recommend? Post your comments below and let me know if you’ve read any of the above – or if you’ve got a hot tip for the Intelligence101 community.

Six [sometimes awkward] Truths About Intelligence Analysis

By Ben Stark on February 9, 2018 0

Six [sometimes awkward] Truths About Intelligence Analysis

Intelligence Analysis is one of the most exciting jobs in the world! But…it can also be boring. Allow me to explain..

Let’s be real. Intelligence is not all lock-picking and high-speed car chases through the streets of Madrid.

This week I’ve been pondering some common misconceptions about the world of intelligence analysis.

So here are some straight truths for budding new Intelligence analysts.

Truth 1 – You need a burning desire to make things better

If you just want to get into intelligence to impress a girl, or because you’re a masochistic idiot who desires to develop a thousand yard stare, GTFO.

Truth 2 – You need a network

In the last James Bond movie, our hero spends the majority of the movie as a rogue agent jet-setting alone from place to place.

In actual fact, you need to know you can count on people, you cannot be a loner.

How do you build your network? Give value to others, give – don’t just take! I find it helps to know what other people are working on and actively share relevant information I find.

Truth 3 – Intelligence Analysts are not ‘born geniuses’

Good intelligence professionals take time each day to sit, read and learn about their craft. They ask good questions and find out what they don’t know.

Truth 4 – You don’t always need to be right

Intelligence is about making the best guess based on the information you have at hand.

If information changes or you get it wrong – brush it off, update your hypothesis and get on with your job.

Being scared to make a call because you’re worried you’ll get it wrong will make you an ineffective analyst. Plain and simple.

Truth 5 – Intelligence. No credit but all the blame

We’ve all heard of Intelligence failures before – but when was the last time you heard of intelligence wins?

Intelligence analysts are sometimes second fiddle to operational staff who often get the credit for a job well done.

I know plenty of analysts who’ve done the heavy lifting in criminal investigations but fail to get the praise.

Guess what? It comes with the territory! Be proud of your own achievements and share your wins with the team.

Truth 6 – Opportunities Abound

When I was in the Army full-time Intelligence staff were always the first to deploy, and often in so many different roles.

If you’re interested in travel, seeing interesting parts of the world, or deploying overseas, intelligence is likely to be your golden ticket.

The Dawning of the Intelligence Age

By Ben Stark on January 1, 2018 0

The Dawning of the Intelligence Age

Allow me to start this post with a bold, but necessary statement:

The’Information Age’ is DEAD!

Welcome to the age of INTELLIGENCE!

About 20 years ago we entered the information age…

Skip forward 20 years and now opinions are like assholes, everyone has one. Whether its Facebook, twitter, youtube, online blogs (excluding this one of course), open source intelligence, forums – such as Reddit or, think tanks, college, and universities and new sites, there’s too much noise.

Sometimes I feel overwhelmed by the amount of information available. It’s like people are all shouting at me, and I constantly bookmark website after website due to some deranged form of Information FOMO.

Sometimes I feel overwhelmed by the amount of information available.

So what’s the answer?Here’s how intelligence analysts can say goodbye to information overload and just focus on collecting relevant information.

Let’s go back to basics…Tell me, what’s the FIRST STEP of the Intelligence Cycle?

Hint: its Direction…

Direction (the first step of the intelligence cycle), is our shining beacon in a world of information excess.

With careful analysis of each information requirement and RFI you receive, direction will be your guiding light out of th deluge of information.

Here’s How…

When the intelligence customer comes to you and says, “I want to know more about this”, or “tell me everything you know about this person” sometimes intelligence analysts dive into the task and start reading / researching and processing reams of reporting assuming the customer needs to know everything… rarely is this the case, however.

By defining the customers’ requirement early, analysts can focus on better collection and provide actionable intelligence without needing to spend hours (sometimes days) speed reading old assessments and trawling through open source reporting.

Use these questions to better define the customers’ requirements; 

  1. What exactly does the customer want to know? -if you don’t know, ask!
  2. Why? (What does the customer intend to do with your answer / assessment)
  3. When does it need to be done? -timeliness vs accuracy
  4. What do they (the customer) already know and think? -find this out so you’re not telling them what they already know!
  5. So what? What does it mean? … and therefore I must? <— Use this to question everything!!
A laser-like focus tunes out the superfluous to make room for the information that really matters

Gone is the day of ‘knowing everything’, today there’s too much information. Focus on the customers’ direction first (and I mean really focus) helps you identify what really matters, and produce better intelligence.

The Intelligence age is all about meaning. It’s about knowing what you want before you begin. Quality vs quantity.

You Don’t Need More Information, You Need to Know What It All Means!

So how can you (as an intelligence analyst) filter out the noise and better determine what it means then?

Use the questions above and take the time at the beginning to analyse your role, and what value you can provide.

If you’re not sure how, try using this email script (below);

– – –
Hi **Boss**, 

Thanks for your email / guidance. 

I understand you’ve requested an intelligence assessment on [topic], 

Before [I / we] get started, I just want to get a little more information about the task / project so I can focus my efforts.

Would you be able to assist by providing a little more information? The more I understand upfront will ultimately help to build a better product.

  • Can you provide me any context for this request? – Why has this come up? Is this due to new or recent information? 
  • What is the intended use of the intelligence assessment? (i.e. how will it inform your decision), and 
  • What do you already know? 

Finally, when do you need this completed by, and how do you want it (written, verbal, email)? 

– – – – –

In summary. The Intelligence Age is all about recognising that information is everywhere, but having the ability to discern what actually matters and what information actually means! Modern Intelligence Analysts need to accept there is often too much information, and they need to develop the critical skills of recognising what’s important – quickly.  The best way I know how to do this is in the direction stage of the Intelligence Cycle. So, use these questions and the script provided to focus your research and create better intelligence by overcome information overload in a noisy world.

Welcome to the Intelligence Age.

 

/rant

My Fool Proof Process to Writing a Killer Intelligence Brief and Tips to Deliver Intelligence Assessments Better

By Ben Stark on December 14, 2017 0

My Fool Proof Process to Writing a Killer Intelligence Brief and Tips to Deliver Intelligence Assessments Better

There’s two parts to this article, Part A is my blueprint for building intelligence briefs. Part B includes my hot tips for Intelligence Analysts to provide assessments in a way your audience can logically follow.

Since I launched Intelligence101 last December (12 months) I’ve seen a steady growth in  readers questions, this post addresses two of my most common questions;

  • Can you tell me how to write intelligence briefs?
  • Are there any secrets or tips to presenting intelligence assessments?

Here’s the answers you’ve been looking for….

Part A: How to Build an Intelligence Brief

This is my process to writing intelligence briefs, think of it as a blueprint. You can use it too…it works!

First, I usually start by asking myself simple questions to frame the assessment and determine my best course of action.

  • Start with the end in mind – what does the customer(s) need / want?
  • How much time do I have?
  • What do I already know about the topic / issue or threat?

Second, I collect as much raw reporting as possible, either open source or existing classified holdings and read as much as I can.

Reading is so important- be curious and consume it all.

I like to work from a blank word document or new power point presentation. I copy and paste as much information and reporting I can find (in the time I’ve got) and delete stuff as I read.  The goal here is to summarise information and categorise it quickly.

Third, Once I’ve conducted an initial trawl of available information, I like to make notes and sort the existing information into different elements (example; stakeholders, environment, risks and threats)

Fourth, Once I establish an understanding of what information exists, if further collection is required, I consider the best source, agency or asset to support that collection and task (read: ask) them to support. While the collection phase is happening  I continue my own research, I tap my own professional network for more information, and to see if anyone has worked on this before. There is no need to reinvent the wheel- try to find efficiencies where possible!

Fifth, As information becomes available, I begin to build my Intelligence brief by adding the main points, key words and assessments into my intelligence briefs. If you’re using a powerpoint slide to deliver your intelligence, I like to supplement each slide with a supporting graphic, map or illustration. (Hint: this is the analysis phase)

If your picture / image / graph or map doesn’t add value to your assessment – get rid of it.

Edit: …Oh also,  clip art cheapens your brief and makes you look a little amateurish. Just saying.

Six, When you’re satisfied you’ve answered the RFI, (or your project deadline looms ominously), present your information in the information obtained, context, assessment format I explain below. This is the easiest way to brief intelligence, regardless whether it’s written in a formal product, presented to an audience or even in an email. Don’t complicate things unnecessarily.

Seven, Prior to delivery I rehearse my brief (with an audience) or I get my peers to proof my [written] work to ensure some of the common questions and there’s no glaring mistakes. It’s better for a peer / colleague to pick up an issue first than be stopped midway through a brief. Trust me, it’s easy to lose your train of thought with an off-topic question.

Tip: Focus on the quality of your content. People won’t worry if your bullet points aren’t aligned if the info is quality. Don’t spend more than 5% on the formatting, editing, cropping and adding graphics to a map trying to make your brief sexy. Good intelligence is sexy enough!

Good intelligence is sexy enough!

If you’re delivering an oral intelligence brief ensure you leave time for a rehearsal. Often rehearsals are neglected, I think they should be mandatory. If your notes don’t make sense to you- they certainly won’t make sense to anyone else! Never present without rehearsing first!

Part B: Delivering Intelligence in a Way Your Audience Can Logically Follow

Information Obtained, Context and Assessment

I was taught a simple yet very effective way of intelligence reporting. I use this every day regardless whether it’s in an email, briefing or detailed assessments. Here it is

Information Obtained – Include information relevant to the question, issue or problem your analysing. In a statement or explanation include the following information;

  • At what time?
  • At what location?
  • What happened?
  • What did the [Unit / Staff / Officers / Facility / Organisation] do?
  • What’s happening next?
  • Who, What, Where, When, Why and How?

Post Card Bandit Example; At 1540hrs on Thursday 14 Dec 17 an unknown criminal successfully robbed the ‘Sunshine City’ commercial bank using only a letter. Information suggests the individual handed a letter to the bank teller which stated he knew the tellers’ full name, her age, and her place of residence. The letter also stated he [the criminal] would harm her family if she did not give him the contents of her bank draw without making a scene. Fearing for her safety the bank teller complied and gave the criminal approximately $3,5000.00 before he snatched the letter back and left the bank. After the individual left the bank, the teller activated the duress alarm and the bank was locked down in accordance with its security policies. The teller has provided a description of the individual to the police onsite and believes she saw him flee in the passenger side of a black Range Rover.

Context – The information here provides context to the information above – i.e. Is this the second time this is reported? Is there a relationship etc. What other information is relevant?

  • Why is this information important / relevant?
  • What has happened before)?
  • Is there other information about this or relevant reporting to support your assessment?

Post Card Bandit Example; On 7th November 17, the ‘Sunshine City’ post office was successfully robbed when a criminal made threats to a staff member written on a postcard. According to police reports after the incident, the individual lined up to purchase a postage stamp but insisted the staff read his post-card before he sent it. According to reports, the postcard contained threats made to the staff member and detailed her personal details such as her full name, phone number, her two children’s names and the school they attend. The criminal left the post office with $1200.00 in cash and left behind the post-card. 

Assessment – This is the so What? What does it mean? Here you’re employed to make an assessment. So, make your assessment.

  • How can / does it affect us?
  • What is likely to happen next?
  • Are their indicators or warnings to identify any courses of action?

Post Card Bandit Example; As this is the second reported incident within a month, it’s assessed this individual is responsible for both the Sunshine City bank and post office robberies. Based on the MO, it’s likely this criminal is undertaking research and preparing for each robbery by choosing a target and either following them physically or conducting a search of the victim’s social media and online profile to use information for his robberies. Due to the relatively low amount of money received in both robberies, it’s assessed the criminal is desperate in his actions, suffering financial pressures possibly from drug addiction, or more likely from loss of employment. It’s assessed the criminal is probably acting with the support of a partner, based on reports about fleeing from the passenger side of the vehicle. A criminal partner would aid the offender in the identification and surveillance of targets for future robberies. Further information about the victims online profile, their pattern of life and CCTV from the bank and post office would aid in the identification of the offender, their methods, and the vehicle used in the two robberies. 

 

Other Resources I recommend on the topic of building / developing intelligence briefs:

“Once Upon a Time” – Intelligence101 Writing an Intelligence Analysis

Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF) Intelligence Writing  Format

 

  • « Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • …
  • Page 10
  • Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Best of Intelligence101

  • Connecting the Dots: How To Use Highlighters To Make Better Sense of Information
  • Fifteen Axioms for Intelligence Analysts
  • How to Become an Intelligence Analyst Today (…even if you’ve got no experience)
  • Intelligence Tradecraft: The Value of Probabilistic Thinking
  • You can now spy on people using your Apple AirPods!

Get Our Newsletter

INTREP: Do You Want To Be A Better Intelligence Analyst? Want Weekly Intelligence Tips and Techniques? Join Our Mailing List Below...

100% privacy. No games, no B.S., no spam. When you sign up, we'll keep you posted with one an email per week.

Categories

  • About Intelligence 101 (1)
  • All Source Intelligence (2)
  • Become A Better Intelligence Analyst (16)
  • Bias (1)
  • Counterintelligence (1)
  • Criminal Intelligence (1)
  • Cyber Intelligence (Hacking) (1)
  • Human Intelligence (HUMINT) (2)
  • Imagery Intelligence (IMINT) (1)
  • Intelligence 101 (10)
  • Intelligence Agencies (3)
  • Intelligence Case Studies (1)
  • Intelligence Resources (2)
  • Measurement and Signature Intelligence (MASINT) (1)
  • Military Intelligence (1)
  • Open Source Intelligence (2)
  • Political Intelligence (1)
  • Psychological Operations (PSYOPS) (2)
  • Resources (2)
    • Product and Service Reviews (2)
  • Security Intelligence (1)
  • SIGINT (1)
  • Spying and Espionage (1)
  • Surveillance (1)
  • Uncategorized (7)

Intelligence Analysts Bookshelf_ Essential Reading For Intelligence Professionals
99 of the BEST Intelligence Resources
Strategic Intelligence & Global Threat Insights: Delivered Everyday by NightWatch
The Ultimate Guide to Human Intelligence (HUMINT)
What University or College Degree Should I Get to Become a Intelligence Analyst?
Tinker, Twitter, Facebook, Spy: Lessons Learnt From The Open Source Intelligence Masterclass
What’s Your Level Of Certainty? On Words of Estimative Probability
PSYOPS: Could this meme be trying to kill you? (Using Memes for Influence Operations)
  • Intelligence 101
  • About
  • Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions
  • Get Started Here
  • Intelligence Frequently Asked Questions
  • Blog Posts

Copyright © 2019 · Smart Passive Income Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in